• Investigations
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Cartoons
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Language
    • 中文
    • русский
    • Español
  • National News
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Elections
  • Civil Liberties
  • Environment
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • Media & Culture
  • MyMPN Announcements

Exploiting Human Tragedy: Manipulating Emotions & Obscuring Facts To Justify Brutal Occupation

November 19, 2014 by Adrian Boutureira

A huge crowd follows a coffin draped in the Israeli flag as it is carried through narrow stone streets in Israel.

Israeli police officers carry the flag draped coffin of Druze Israeli police officer Zidan Sif in the Druze village of Yanuh-Jat, northern Israel, Wednesday, Nov. 19, 2014. Sif, 30, died of his wounds on Tuesday after Two Palestinian cousins armed with meat cleavers and a gun stormed a Jerusalem synagogue during morning prayers Tuesday, killing four people. Police killed the attackers in a shootout. (AP Photo/Ariel Schalit)

I think that the loss of any innocent life from violence is regrettable. The question of innocence in situations where one people is collectively attempting to brutally dominate can always be academically debated, but I have no intention to introduce such arguments here nor to try to explain away this violence or diminish, in any way, the human suffering that it causes. It’s not necessary.

Instead, I want to express my sense of injustice in how our society’s emotions can be manipulated so easily into outrage at the killing of any Israeli at the hands of Palestinians, while consistently ignoring many more such attacks on Palestinians by Israelis. I find this one sided reaction rather disturbing in its bias, hypocrisy and blatant racism. The government and media feed and promote this reaction. They create criminally manipulative propaganda through their presentation of the facts and their context.

Let me put things in perspective to illustrate my point:

During the recent bombing of Gaza, 2,150 people were killed. Of this total, 76% were civilians. Of these, 500 were children and 253 women. In these same attacks, 17,200 homes and 244 schools were damaged and thousands were left homeless. It will take billions of dollars and decades to repair all the damage to infrastructure. The life and future of hundreds of thousands of people will never be the same.

In the same conflict, Israel suffered 68 casualties. All but 5 of these were soldiers. There was no property damage or mass civilian displacement or humanitarian crisis inside Israel whatsoever.

What have you really heard in terms of outrage and condemnation by the mainstream media or by our government about all of this?

And what about over this?

Since that genocidal attack, the Israeli government and Israeli civilians have continued to appropriate land, harass the population, demolish homes, burn mosques, defile holy sites, and attack and kill Palestinians. Even as I write this, Israeli civilians are attacking Palestinians and the Israeli government is destroying the homes of the killed attackers. Like so many others, it’s an act of illegal collective punishment carried out against the family of the attackers. The ones responsible are already dead, and therefore will not not suffer from that retaliatory act of state-sponsored terror.

It’s true that the history of this conflict shows that there are two sides involved. But that same tragic history shows one side consistently and increasingly occupying and stealing the land of the other side since 1948. It shows that one side has an army, a navy and and an air force, and the other doesn’t. And one side receives billions of dollars in US aid and gets to carry out any criminal act it wishes with total impunity, while the other is chronically impoverished and completely deprived by the former of even the most basic human rights.

One side is the oppressor, and the other the oppressed.

This social, economic, political and historical aberration caused by the Israeli occupation of historic Palestine has indeed produced tragic results for both sides. Real tragedies that have shattered equally the lives of both Israelis and Palestinians. But while equal in their result, these ensuing tragedies are not uniform in their root cause. They are actually distinctly different in that way.

Injustice is a major vehicle of such equal, but differently informed tragedies. It is knowledge of the facts that constitutes this difference. Knowledge helps one understand that while a tragedy is a tragedy is a tragedy, when these come about grossly disproportionately and as a result of one side’s institutionalized brutal injustice, one can’t hardly honestly view them as the same, neither in scope nor the responsibility for their root cause.

Content posted to MyMPN open blogs is the opinion of the author alone, and should not be attributed to MintPress News.

Filed Under: Civil Liberties, Foreign Affairs Tagged With: Gaza, genocide, Human Rights, Islamophobia, Israel, Jerusalem, mainstream media, media, occupation, Occupied West Bank, Palestine, Protective Edge, racism, Synagogue Attack, terrorism, West Bank, Zionism

Comments

  1. Kit O'Connell says

    November 19, 2014 at 7:09 pm

    Another thought-provoking and well aimed article, Adrian. The hypocrisy of the mainstream media has been out in the open for all to see since the tragic Synagogue Attack — it’s been all “Palestinians celebrate death” and zero context about the suffering they’ve undergone or the relative scale of the tragedies. So I really appreciate you putting this perspective on the incident.

    Reply
  2. Mark C Austin says

    November 23, 2014 at 8:25 pm

    Are you serious with this? How are the Palestinans oppressed when all they want is the complete and total ANNIHILATION of the Israelis and Jews around the world?! Since when was their land “taken” from them? You do realize that there was NEVER a country named Palestine EVER?! The ROMANS named the area Palestine. However, there was once an Israel and those lands BELONGED to the Jews thousands of years ago. The area has been fought over for millenia. Another interesting little factoid is is that if you are an ARAB CITIZEN of Israel you can hold political office be a Judge serve in the Military become a cop be a teacher, there are no restrictions on you because you are not Jewish! There are no jobs in Palestine or decent housing and schooling-not because of Israeli oppression but rather because the government there- which is Hamas a terrorist organization-took all the money and supplies given to them BY THE ISRAELI government to build schools hospitals and housing and used it to build TUNNELS to carry out their chicken shit terrorist attacks on innocent civilians in ISrael. So tell me again how the Israelis are barbaric and the oppressors. Please I really need to understand your thinking if that’s what you want to call it!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About MyMPN

MyMPN is MintPress News' community site. Anyone can participate by writing a diary and commenting on others' diaries.

Content posted to MyMPN is the opinion of the author alone, and should not be attributed to MintPress News.

MyMPN will cease publishing on January 15, 2017. Thank you for your support of our work.

  • More about MyMPN
  • Report site problems and bugs
  • MyMPN Comment Moderation

Follow Mintpress

RSSTwitterFacebookGooglePlus

Our Latest Posts

In The Age Of Trump, Peaceful Revolt Is Our Only Option

By Kevin Patrick Kelly January 11, 2017

Hafizah Geter Gives Moving Poetic ‘Testimony’ At Medgar Evers College

By José Negroni January 10, 2017

Gonzo Journalism Rejects The Myth Of The Neutral Media

By Dr. Milena Rampoldi January 9, 2017

Aleppo: How The US Manipulates Humanitarianism For Imperialism

By Steven Chovanec January 6, 2017

Why One ‘Remain’ Voter Now Supports A Hard Brexit

By Tara Lighten Msiska January 5, 2017

Hawaiian Kingdom, American Empire: An Interview With Professor Keanu Sai

By Dennis Riches January 4, 2017

War Against Rape In Karachi: Advocating For A Rape Free Society

By Dr. Milena Rampoldi December 30, 2016

What’s In A Name? From ‘Al-Qaeda’ To The ‘Kingdom Of Saudi Arabia’

By Nu’man Abd al-Wahid December 29, 2016

Popular Tags

activism Africa American imperialism Barack Obama Canada capitalism Climate change democracy Democratic Party Donald Trump Egypt election 2016 energy fracking history Human Rights inequality Iraq ISIS Islam Islamic State Israel journalism MENA Middle East mining nuclear oil Palestine police poverty prison propaganda racism Republican Party Russia Saudi Arabia Syria terrorism Texas United Kingdom United Nations Wall Street War water

Sign up for our Daily Newsletter

Copyright © 2022 Mint Press, LLC