Journey To Aleppo Part II: The Syria Civil Defense & Aleppo Medical Association Are Real Syrians Helping Real Syrians

Vanessa Beeley meets with members of the Syria Civil Defense and the Aleppo Medical Association, who shed more light on the mainstream media lies distorting the public’s perception of what’s really happening in Syria.
By |
Be Sociable, Share!
    • Google+
    Aleppo Medical Association

    A bombed-out building that’s been converted into a terrorist sniper tower with barrels and sandbags in Sheikh Maqsoud, the Kurdish-held area in northern Aleppo. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    Editor’s Note: This article is the second in a two-part series of one Western journalist’s journey to Aleppo, a city ravaged by an insurgency supported by the United States, NATO member states, and their allies in the Gulf states and Israel.


    In Part I, Vanessa Beeley lays out the mainstream narrative on Syria, revealing a neoconservative agenda promoted by NATO-funded NGOs. These NGOs paint the destruction of the historic city as being caused by the Syrian government under Syrian President Bashar Assad, not the violent armed insurgents which receive arms, funding and training from Western governments and their allies in the Gulf and Israel.


    Part II focuses on the suffering and resilience she encountered among the Syrian people in western Aleppo, an area that’s been under siege by the Nusra Front and other “moderate rebel” groups and “opposition forces” for the last four years.


    ALEPPO, Syria — From the town of Bani Zaid in northern Aleppo, we made our way to the Aleppo Medical Association in the al-Azizia district of Aleppo.

    We met with Dr. Zahar Buttal, the director, and Dr. Bassem Hayak, who heads the psychological and malnutrition trauma units which, among their many services, treat civilians who manage to flee terrorist-held eastern Aleppo into the government-held western Aleppo via the humanitarian corridors established by Russian and Syrian authorities.

    Dr. Zahar Buttal, director of the Aleppo Medical Association, standing next to photos of previous directors at the Aleppo Medical Association building. (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    Dr. Zahar Buttal, director of the Aleppo Medical Association, standing next to photos of previous directors at the Aleppo Medical Association building.

    More than 2,000 civilians–mostly women and children–had been received not long prior to our visit, Dr. Hayak said. They flooded into western Aleppo via the humanitarian corridors that were opened on July 29, the day after Syrian President Bashar Assad issued the amnesty decree for all armed factions embedded throughout eastern Aleppo.

    Dr. Hayak’s team stationed medical groups at the exits of the humanitarian corridors to receive civilians before sending them to designated houses for medical evaluations. Initially, three humanitarian corridors were in operation, with four others to be opened at a later date.

    He also said that only three main hospitals exist in eastern Aleppo: Al-Daqqaq, Al-Zahraa, and the Omar bin Abdulaziz Hospital, founded and built by the Grand Mufti Ahmad Badreddin Hassoun and various other charities.

    This runs counter to the NATO-aligned media and humanitarian NGO complex narrative, which gives the impression that there are at least ten hospitals in eastern Aleppo without differentiating between the facilities or the services they provide and to whom. Western media infers that those being targeted are civilians, not members of the Nusra Front and other foreign-funded terrorist brigades, and that all these “civilians” are being mercilessly bombed by Russian and Syrian air strikes.

    All three main hospitals are fully occupied by the various armed insurgencies led by the Nusra Front, according to Dr. Hayak, who said they use the top floors as sniper towers. Terrorists–the various groups of so-called “moderate rebels” and “opposition forces” backed by the United States, NATO member states, their Gulf State allies and Israel–take priority over civilians, and only surgical intervention is now carried out in the three hospitals in eastern Aleppo. The armed insurgents refuse to allow U.N. agencies inside these facilities, according to Dr. Hayak.

    In addition to the three main hospitals, there are seven other, less well-equipped private health clinics also under terrorist control, according to Dr. Hayak.

    One of the primary producers of propaganda regarding the hospitals being targeted in eastern Aleppo is Doctors Without Borders, the international aid NGO often referred to by its French acronym, MSF. MSF laid claim to al-Quds Hospital, which was allegedly targeted on April 27 by a variety of missiles, according to conflicting reports from Pablo Marco, the NGO’s Middle East operations manager.

    In an open letter to MSF dated May 4, Rick Sterling, a geopolitical analyst and writer, pointed out these glaring discrepancies and a number of other flagrant anomalies in the MSF reports:

    “There are many discrepancies in reports about the April 27 attack on Al Quds Hospital. MSF Middle East Operations Manager Pablo Marco, interviewed the next day on CNN and PBS Newshour, said ‘there were two barrel bombs that fell close to the hospital …. then the third barrel bomb fell in the entrance of the hospital’. Barrel bombs are only delivered by helicopters. In contrast, your press release the same day says ‘the hospital was destroyed by at least one airstrike which directly hit the building, reducing it to rubble.’ A CBC report continued this version, claiming ‘An MSF-supported hospital in the northern Syria city of Aleppo is now a pile of rubble. Airstrikes brought down the building on Wednesday.’”

    Dr. Nabil Antaki, a gastroenterologist based in western Aleppo, also questioned the objectivity of the MSF reports and the Western media narrative. In a statement to Arret sur Info (my translation can be found here) on May 1, he said:

    “For three days now, these media outlets have been accusing the ‘Assad regime’ of bombing an MSF hospital [Medecins sans Frontieres] to the east of Aleppo and of killing the last paediatrician in the city. This demonstrates that, for these media, the only priority is this pocket of the city where terrorists are embedded.

    The three quarters of Aleppo under Syrian Government control where numerous paediatricians are practicing is of no consequence for this media.”

    Dr. Hayak of the Aleppo Medical Association estimated that 200,000 to 220,000 people are living in eastern Aleppo, including 50,000 members of the armed insurgencies and their families. The area’s civilian population has been driven from their homes, and the majority are living without shelter or work, fearing for their lives if they try to escape or protest the occupation of terrorist-held eastern Aleppo. Young men, in particular, are either co-opted into the terrorist ranks or killed if they try to leave even via the humanitarian corridors.

    During our talk, I filmed Dr. Hayak when I asked him about the the White Helmets, a group which claims to operate as first responders in terrorist-held eastern Aleppo.

    Dr. Hayak described how none of his relatives or family friends in eastern Aleppo know of this organization which is embedded only in the Nusra Front strongholds in Aleppo, Idlib and other governorates across Syria. According to their own promotional literature and videos, the White Helmets operate extensively in eastern Aleppo, “saving all humanity when the bombs fall.” So it is revealing, that according to Dr. Hayak, they are virtually unknown to the civilians and official aid organizations, like the U.N., World Health Organization, and Red Crescent, living or working in eastern Aleppo.

    During this interview, Dr. Hayak also stated that the civilians in eastern Aleppo are held hostage by the Nusra Front. Should anyone attempt to leave for Syrian government-held western Aleppo, their families are threatened with execution. He cited the case of his cousin, a surgeon, who is unable to leave to work in western Aleppo because her family would be killed. She is forced to continue working for the Nusra Front-occupied hospitals, mostly treating terrorists.

    Watch Vanessa Beeley’s interview with Dr. Bassem Hayak:

    One Aleppo resident told Ruptly in July:

    “The government gave the opportunity for civilians to come here, but the rebels are not letting them; they are shooting at them. This is not acceptable. The ‘rebels’ should let the civilians come here to avoid bloodshed. Those are our relatives, our people. If the civilians come here we can save the babies and the women. If the rebels want to fight they can fight, why include the civilians?”

    On Sept. 19, however, videos emerged of civilians fleeing areas in Aleppo held by the Nusra Front via humanitarian corridors. Even as they rush to safety, shielded by Syrian Arab Army soldiers, the civilians are fired upon by the Western-backed “moderate rebels” and “opposition forces.”

    Watch “Syria: Aleppo residents flee fighting through humanitarian corridors” from Ruptly TV:

    Video posted to Facebook by Sayyed Ali News:


    ‘Those who called themselves MSF were standing side by side with the terrorists’

    Over the course of several meetings with Syria’s Grand Mufti Ahmad Badreddin Hassoun in July and August, the Grand Mufti emphasized that the hospitals, including his own project, the Omar bin Abdulaziz Hospital, were occupied by terrorists.

    The Grand Mufti has been a fierce advocate of the Syrian secular state and an outspoken critic of NATO’s dirty war on Syria. According to the Grand Mufti and to the majority of Syrians I met during my four weeks in Syria, it is a war that’s been fomented along sectarian lines that never existed prior to this externally imposed crisis.

    Grand Mufti Ahmad Badreddin Hassoun during a meeting with Vanessa Beeley on Aug. 24.  (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    Grand Mufti Ahmad Badreddin Hassoun during a meeting with Vanessa Beeley on Aug. 24.  (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    During one of our talks, the Grand Mufti said:

    “This association [the Grand Mufti’s charity] for raising standards has been licensed in Syria since 1955. I have built that hospital with my money and with donations from people who have worked with us, starting from 1985. That hospital started operating in 1992, and we used to treat the poor people from the neighborhood. The hospital is located in a poor area, and we used to treat more than 400 people per day for free. The hospital had nine dialysis machines. When the terrorists came they drove out the doctors, killed three nurses, and killed more than 10 patients inside the hospital before taking over the hospital.

    They then claimed that MSF is the one operating the hospital, but in that hospital they receive only terrorists, no civilians who remain in the neighborhood. There was a group of terrorists standing guard at the front door of hospital, they have not allowed the maternity department to operate since 2013. There were 12 premature baby incubators–all stolen. They kept the hospital like a field hospital to treat terrorists. That is the hospital [we] built with our own hands and now they lie and say it’s their hospital.

    Those who call themselves MSF were standing side by side with the terrorists to kill our children and to requisition charity hospitals, schools and associations. That is what was done in Aleppo.”

    Grand Mufti Ahmad Badreddin Hassoun. (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    Grand Mufti Ahmad Badreddin Hassoun. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)



    Propaganda merchants silent on terrorist attacks on western Aleppo

    During our meeting on Aug. 15, Dr. Zahar Buttal informed us that, from Aug. 1 to to 14, 143 civilians, including 54 children and 23 women, had been murdered by terrorist missile attacks in western Aleppo. The routinely worst hit areas are shown on the map below; Aziziya, where we stayed in during our visit, was also regularly targeted by terrorist mortar fire and explosive ammunition.

    Map showing the areas of western Aleppo hit hardest by the Nusra Front and other terror groups’ “hell cannon” mortar fire. (Screenshot provided by Vanessa Beeley)

    Map showing the areas of western Aleppo hit hardest by the Nusra Front and other terror groups’ “hell cannon” mortar fire. (Screenshot provided by Vanessa Beeley)

    During our meeting with the Aleppo Medical Association, news came in of two armored vehicles packed with explosives driving into the Zahraa residential area of northern Aleppo.

    Perhaps coincidentally, Riyadh-educated Sheikh Abdallah al-Muhaysini, chief of the Nusra Front, had been issuing one of his regular calls for suicide bomber volunteers just two days prior to our visit. This time, the call had gone out meters away from Aleppo’s ancient citadel walls.

    That call was apparently heeded by the two men who drove armored vehicles packed with enough explosives to massacre hundreds of civilians. Dr. Hayak explained that the trucks had bulletproof windscreens that the drivers would not have been able to see out of, so they were guided into their target by radio instructions.

    However, the trucks were successfully intercepted by airstrikes that destroyed them before they could complete their deadly mission. No civilian casualties were reported, but it was yet another Western-backed attack by “moderate rebels” and “opposition forces” not reported in Western media.


    ‘We are disgusted by these sanctions’

    An Aug. 31 statement from the Syrian American Council made the extraordinary claim that because Syrian blood banks have historically been run by the country’s defense ministry, the blood stored in those banks is being given to soldiers as a priority over civilians. That statement reads:

    “SAC wishes to note that even payments to seemingly innocuous regime-linked sources can be rerouted to Assad’s killing machine. For example, the UN has made millions of dollars in payments to Assad’s fuel supplier, which also fuels the warplanes bombing Syrian civilians; to Assad’s Agriculture Ministry, which also feeds the regime troops storming Syrian cities and towns; and to Assad’s blood bank, despite ‘concrete concerns’ that the blood would be reserved for regime troops. SAC has received countless reports over the years of UN aid in fact being used by Assad soldiers.”

    The statement effectively calls upon the United States to further perpetuate the suffering of the Syrian people — people who are already being collectively punished by the crippling U.S. and EU sanctions that affect all sectors of civilian life, including health, agriculture, and education.

    Speaking to Be Curious TV in May (my translation can be found here), Dr. Nabil Antaki said:

    “We are disgusted by these sanctions because these sanctions and these embargoes have not been implemented against the Syrian government but against the Syrian people, all the Syrian people. For example, me personally, as person x, living in Syria, does not have the right to conduct the smallest transaction. If I wanted to send $1,000 to my children, I am unable to do so. I can neither import or export anything. This is crippling. I am a doctor, I wanted to replace one part of a piece of medical equipment.  Normally this would take one week; it took a year and a half to get hold of the part because we couldn’t import it from Japan, as it was a multinational company.

    So these sanctions penalize the Syrian people and at a certain moment the EU lifted the sanctions but only for the people living in the terrorist-controlled zones. Those people living in areas under the control of the Syrian state could do nothing. Contrary to their claims, this does not penalize the ‘regime,’ it punishes the Syrian people.”

    Maria Saadeh, a member of the Syrian parliament, in Damascus on Aug 22. (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    Maria Saadeh, a member of the Syrian parliament, in Damascus on Aug 22. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    In March 2015, a member of the Syrian parliament, Maria Saadeh, addressed the United Nations Human Rights Commission in Geneva, presenting a paper titled, “Unilateral Economic Sanctions against Syria and Terrorism: Two sides of the same coin.”

    In June 2016, Saadeh addressed the UN again. Speaking at the Institute of Democracy and Co-operation’s side event at the UNHRC’s session in Geneva, she said:

    “Economic sanctions have been applied to punish the Syrian regime. Since 2011, member states of the UN have undertaken collective punitive action against the Syrian people. In March 2015, I presented here at the Human Rights Council a document entitled ‘economic terrorism’ which compared the results of terrorist organisations in Syria with the effects of coercive measures taken under the label of ‘economic sanctions.’

    These sanctions violate international law in the same way as terrorism does. Their results and effects are the same; the aim in both cases is to attack Syrian society and to violate human rights, especially the right to life.  

    As a result of the sanctions, unemployment has risen from 8.6% in 2010 to 50% in 2014; poverty reached 75% in 2013 where it was 9% in 2010; the number of children in primary education has fallen to 50%; the same number of hospitals and factories have closed as a result of the sanctions as as a result of terrorism. In the same paper, I also showed the relations between the states applying the sanctions and the terrorist organisations they support. I also discuss the relationship between them in despoiling Syria of its natural, economic and cultural resources.”


    Giving blood in Aleppo

    While we were in western Aleppo, we decided to give blood, which seemed particularly critical after just hearing about the increasing numbers of civilians maimed and mutilated by terrorist missiles, explosive bullets and mortars, and gas attacks.

    Eva Bartlett and Vanessa Beeley giving blood in Aleppo on Aug. 15, 2016. (Photo provided by Vanessa Beeley)

    Eva Bartlett and Vanessa Beeley giving blood in Aleppo on Aug. 15, 2016. (Photo provided by Vanessa Beeley)

    The blood banks in Syria rely on daily donations to keep hospitals stocked with enough blood to cope with the increase in terrorist rockets against civilian areas in government-held areas of western Aleppo and across Syria.

    We were told that a few days before we arrived in Aleppo, a group of 250 teachers had come in to donate blood. Just after we finished, a young man entered to give blood for his brother who had been critically injured in a recent “moderate rebel” shelling attack. Like so many others, the injured brother was hospitalized and required a daily blood transfusion to survive.

    A friend from Aleppo later told me that he had requested that his blood be given to the Syrian Arab Army as his recognition of their bravery in defending Aleppo. He said he was told unequivocally that the blood bank would not agree to that. Blood would be given to those who need it most urgently, blood bank workers said, adding that there would be no prioritizing.

    Like so many aspects of Syrian life, the blood storage units have been adversely affected by U.S. and EU sanctions. In Aleppo they ran out of plastic blood storage bags and they have had to improvise an alternate storage system–one of the innumerable ways Syrians have adapted to a crisis with resourcefulness and invention.

    In light of what we heard and witnessed in the Aleppo blood bank, the Syrian American Council’s statement is another example of the propaganda that ensures the misery and suffering of the Syrian people has no end until the neocolonial objectives of the United States, European Union, and NATO members are achieved.


    The White Helmets are not the Syria Civil Defense

    One of the main reasons that I stayed in Syria for four weeks, was to continue a long-running investigation into the White Helmets. This group is funded and equipped by the United States, United Kingdom, EU and Japan. The White Helmets are trained by former British military,mercenary, James Le Mesurier, and are often referred to as the “Syrian Civil Defense.”

    The alleged first responder group is embedded exclusively in areas held by terrorist groups like the Nusra Front and Daesh (an Arabic acronym for the terrorist group known in the West as ISIS or ISIL).

    The White Helmets paint a picture of humanitarian catastrophe in western Aleppo to facilitate NATO’s goal of generating public support for a no-fly zone and more sanctions against Syria. Crimes committed by the Nusra Front and the myriad terrorist groups in Aleppo are portrayed as those of the Syrian government and armed forces.

    The White Helmets were established in 2013, and despite making claims of impartiality and independence, they have received over $50 million in funding from the United States and United Kingdom alone.

    Infographic produced by UK Column for Vanessa Beeley showing the James Le Mesurier & White Helmet’s deep state connections.

    Infographic produced by UK Column for Vanessa Beeley showing the James Le Mesurier & White Helmet’s deep state connections.

    However, an updated entry in Wikipedia demonstrates clearly, the multi-million dollar funding tap that has been turned on for this US & NATO shadow state construct.  This phony first responder unit is nothing more than a NATO state and US funded invention being deployed alongside US & NATO funded & armed terrorist brigades inside Syria. They exist to produce the regime change, No Fly Zone,  justifying propaganda and to support an army of mercenaries and genetically modified terrorists.

    “SCD is supported by the aid agencies of a number of external donor governments. Initially the United Kingdom Foreign and Commonwealth Office was the largest single source of funding through the newly constructed aid group, Mayday Rescue, then based in Istanbul though headquartered in the Netherlands.[26] Now funders include the Danish government, the German government, [24] the Japan International Cooperation Agency,[23] United States Agency for International Development (USAID),[27] the United Kingdom Conflict, Stability and Security Fund (CSSF),[28] and the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs.[29]USAID now appears to be the largest donor, having contributed at least $23 million since 2013”

    At an April 27 press briefing, Mark Toner, a State Department deputy spokesman, publicly admitted that the State Department funded this outreach operation with $23 million via USAID. About a week before that briefing, however, the leader of the group, Raed Saleh, was denied entry to the United States when he arrived on a flight from Istanbul to Washington in April.

    After Toner relayed the United States’ condemnation of a recent aerial attack on a station of the “Syrian Civil Defense,” one journalist at the press briefing asked Toner: “You’re saying that basically he is suspect but his group is not?” To which Toner replied that the State Department is “not condemning the group in any way whatsoever.”


    In a disturbing development that received little media coverage, Saleh, who had been deported for unexplained reasons in April, was allowed to enter the United States this month. On Sept. 22, he reportedly accompanied the Dutch Mission to the United Nations in New York.

    That same day, Secretary of State John Kerry tweeted his support for the White Helmets, a group which already enjoys plenty of financial and training support from the United States, United Kingdom and European Union.

    This is not the first time the United States has entertained suspect or questionable individuals with “extremist connections.” In December 2015, Labib al-Nahhas, the self-proclaimed “chief of Foreign Political Relations at Ahrar al-Sham,” was allowed entry into the United States.

    The United States protects Ahrar al-Sham’s ties to both Daesh and al-Qaida from being exposed, thus enabling the group to carry out its policy of mass murder and ethnic cleansing of minorities inside Syria. It’s able to do so not just unhindered, but with the tacit approval of the U.S. government.

    In a May 2016 report for McClatchy, Hannah Allam wrote:

    “A senior figure from a Syrian rebel group with links to al Qaida was allowed into the United States for a brief visit, raising questions about how much the Obama administration will compromise in the search for partners in the conflict.”  

    I’ve amassed a body of work, “Who are Syria’s White Helmets?,” which exposes the White Helmets, a group Toner also refers to as the “Syrian Civil Defense,” as sectarian fifth columnists armed and funded by Western neo-colonialists and who operate as a terrorist support group.

    The White Helmets, it should be noted, are not the real Syria Civil Defense. And efforts to refer to the group as such are an affront to the real Syria Civil Defense, the members of which risk their lives every day to protect the Syrian people.

    There’s no public phone number where the White Helmets can be reached in Syria. To reach the real Syria Civil Defense in Syria, though, one only needs to dial 113.


    The real Syria Civil Defense

    In the university area of western Aleppo, we pulled into one of the real Syria Civil Defense’s centres. Aleppo University was targeted by terrorist rocket fire in January 2013, which killed 87 and injured over 160. It was an attack designed to inflict maximum damage, taking place on the first day of exams.

    The real Syria Civil Defense’s Aleppo Headquarters are in Hamdaniyah, one of the areas regularly pummelled by the mortars and missiles fired by the various groups of armed insurgents.

    When we were met by the crew of this unit, I was immediately struck by the exhaustion etched on their faces, their ramshackle sleeping quarters, the paucity of equipment, and the worn, threadbare condition of the various boots, hoses and jackets that were on the ground or hanging from the fire truck doors and fenders.

    Boots and a fire hose sit in the corner of the yard of the real Syria Civil Defense, waiting for the next call. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    Boots and a fire hose sit in the corner of the yard of the real Syria Civil Defense, waiting for the next call. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    From 11:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. on Aug. 15, they had been battling a fire in a plastics factory that was sparked by terrorist mortar attacks on the area.

    The crew was initially hesitant to go into too much depth about their operations or the White Helmets, but they eventually opened up.

    The Syria Civil Defense organization was established in 1953. The Aleppo crews currently have around 150 volunteers who are fully-trained paramedics with extensive training in all aspects of search and rescue. The volunteers are between 25 and 45, and the minimum age for joining and training is 18.

    One of the real Syria Civil Defense’s fire engines parked at their unit in western Aleppo. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    One of the real Syria Civil Defense’s fire engines parked at their unit in western Aleppo. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    The crew said they were called out to a heavy “hell cannon” attack on the old citadel in central Aleppo on Aug. 2. Upon arriving on the scene, they noticed a pungent smell in the air which warned them of a toxic gas attack by the Nusra Front.

    They were wearing lightweight paper oxygen masks. Because of U.S. and EU sanctions being imposed on Syria, these rescue workers are unable to replace their supply of high-spec gas masks that would have been a lifesaver on many occasions.

    The concentration of gas was so high that the flimsy oxygen masks did not effectively prevent the toxic fumes entering their lungs. One of the crew members, Mohammed Ahmed Eibbish, 36, died while trying to rescue a woman from an affected building.

    Other crew members and civilians reported symptoms of gas poisoning, such as dizziness, nausea, burns, spasms, and difficulty breathing. Four women died from inhaling toxic fumes during this attack, and 25 civilians were affected and hospitalized as a result.

    Rather than report on these chemical attacks by “moderate rebels,” the mainstream media prefers to apportion blame to the Syrian government and the Syrian Arab Army despite the fact that the only chemical factory in Aleppo was taken over by the Nusra Front in 2012.

    A helmet used by the real Syria Civil Defense is perched on the dashboard, ready for action.  (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    A helmet used by the real Syria Civil Defense is perched on the dashboard, ready for action.  (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    We then got onto the subject of the White Helmets, who portray themselves as the Syrian Civil Defense, despite the long history and continued operations of the very real, and genuinely heroic, Syria Civil Defense.

    One member of the crew told us that he had been stationed in eastern Aleppo when the terrorists, including those who later morphed into the White Helmets, began to arrive around 2012. Some members of the existing Syria Civil Defense were kidnapped and some were murdered, and this crew member said the terrorist groups demanded that he join them. He managed to escape at night into western Aleppo but was forced to leave behind his three sons.

    In retaliation, the same groups of terrorists burned his house to the ground and his name was put on all the checkpoints manned by terrorist groups, including the Nusra Front, in eastern Aleppo, ensuring that he would be executed if he ever returned. He said his teenage sons are taking care of themselves, but he fears for their safety.

    Members of the group told me I could not publish any photos or names of the members of the Syria Civil Defense because of the huge security risks associated with their proximity to terrorist positions. These terrorists, they said, have marked them for assassination.

    These are the same terrorist groups that the White Helmets support, celebrate with and live among. Yet the White Helmets are praised as saints and saviors by the well-oiled George Soros and U.S. government-manipulated propaganda apparatus.

    The crew members all described how the White Helmets don’t carry out any rescue operations in Aleppo; they are weapons-carrying mercenaries described by the REAL Syria Civil Defense as “terrorists.” The use of the word “rebel” is scorned and despised by the majority of Syrians who do not support “killing Syria to improve Syria,” as Dr. Nabil Antaki told Be Curious TV in an interview in May (a translated transcript of that interview can be found here).

    Some of the White Helmets are from Aleppo, but others were brought in from outside Aleppo and even from outside Syria, the members of the real Syria Civil Defense said.

    Quote taken from the Be Curious TV interview with Dr. Nabil Antaki. (Courtesy of Vanessa Beeley)

    Quote taken from the Be Curious TV interview with Dr. Nabil Antaki. (Courtesy of Vanessa Beeley)

    At the same time that members of the real Syria Civil Defense were routed, murdered, and kidnapped in 2012, the incoming terrorists and White Helmets-to-be stole equipment from the group, including three fire engines and all of their ambulances.

    And while the U.S. and U.K. governments praise the White Helmets as heroes, Netflix produces a documentary about their Hollywood-style exploits, the Middle East Institute, which counts former U.S. Ambassador to Syria Robert Ford as a member, nominates the group for the Nobel Peace Prize, these members of the real Syria Civil Defense have been risking their lives and the lives of their families to rescue civilians from the terrorist missile onslaught and invasion of their homeland.

    The worst injuries they see are from the “hell cannon”-fired gas canisters, which are often filled with glass and metal that rip into children’s bodies and tear limbs apart.

    One crew member broke both his legs jumping from a targeted building during a rescue operation. Another lost an eye in a “hell cannon” attack.

    They work 24-hour shifts, often without a break.

    Asked why he continues this volunteer work, one member of the real Syria Civil Defense replied: “It is humanitarian work for our country. We were there in the good times, and we are here when the times are bad and we are needed most. It’s our duty.”

    These are the heroes ignored by the world which chooses instead to focus on the obscene parody that is the White Helmets.

    When asked what they’d tell the United States, NATO member states and their allies in the Gulf states and Israel which are enabling the war on Syria, the first responders said:

    • Lift the sanctions so they can keep doing their work;
    • Stop the terrorists from entering Syria, and stop funding and arming them;
    • If terrorists keep entering Syria, eventually it will affect the world, not just Syria. There has been enough bloodshed. It needs to stop now.


    ‘Nobody listens to us. Why?’

    After a meeting-packed 36 hours we decided to stroll around the small park in al-Azizia district.

    Two men enjoying a moment of respite from the war raging around them. (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    Two men enjoying a moment of respite from the war raging around them. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    Here, we were greeted by a mix of refugees, families, and students enjoying a brief respite from the war that was being fought around them.

    One man who was in the park with his grandchildren told me he was a professor of English who had spent a lot of time abroad in Europe and the United States. He said:

    The people in Europe simply don’t believe us when we tell them what is really happening in Syria. When I was in Europe I realized they all still think we have tails beneath our dresses. Here it is just perpetual bombing and nobody listens to us. Why?”

    The streets of western Aleppo are dotted with the Syrian flag, either painted on doors as it is across so much of Syria or billowing in the wind from balconies or shopfronts. Displaying the flag in any way is a proud defiance of the U.S.-backed “moderate rebels” and their corrupted national flag that is an insult to the majority of the Syrian people and the Syrian Arab Army which is giving its all to cleanse Syria of the terrorist invasion.

    The Syrian flag painted in proud defiance onto storefront shutters in western Aleppo. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    The Syrian flag painted in proud defiance onto storefront shutters in western Aleppo. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    We left at dawn the next day. As I took the bags down the flights of stairs to the street below, I noticed two women chatting animatedly across the way. Life goes on in Aleppo, stubbornly and defiantly.

    Two ladies have an animated chat at dawn in Aziziya, western Aleppo. (Photo by Vanessa Beeley)

    Two ladies have an animated chat at dawn in Aziziya, western Aleppo. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    The dust settled on the road behind us as we passed a checkpoint where we were told: “Put your foot down. There is a high risk of mortar fire.”

    It was then that the enormity of the mainstream media lies and obscurantism really began to hit home. We had entered the NATO-erected propaganda tent and we had found the truth, not from the propaganda mill but from the Syrian people living through the hell that has been imposed upon them by Western governments, NATO member states, and their allies in the Gulf states and Israel–all of whom are intent upon pursuing their geopolitical agenda in the region with scant regard for the bloodshed they’re leaving in their wake.

    I went to Syria, and specifically to Aleppo, because, as journalists, investigators, analysts it’s our job, our obligation, and our duty to dismantle every story back to its roots and verify its truth. I have failed to see Western mainstream media do this. All too often they support a knee-jerk government foreign policy response that inevitably ratchets up the pressure on a target nation, with their own amplification of the propaganda that conveniently justifies non-peaceful resolution of a conflict and escalation of proxy or direct military intervention.  

    None of us will get it right all the time, but we owe it to the people who are directly affected and damaged by these lies, to do our utmost to produce the closest we can get to the truth. That is not done by sitting at a desk in Washington, Paris or London and relying upon reports from Western government-funded institutions and deep state outreach units masquerading as activists, citizen journalists and humanitarians. It is done by going to Syria and talking to the people on the ground, the majority of whom are living in government-held areas for good reason.

    Nobody understood propaganda better than Adolf Hitler, and nobody practices this form of intellectual conceit better than the Mockingbird mainstream media. The Syrian people deserve better. They deserve to be heard and to be allowed to decide their own future free from hostile media, hostile sanctions and hostile occupation by mercenaries and terrorists backed by the United States, NATO, and their allies in the Gulf states and Israel–a criminal occupation that no amount of rebranding or Manhattan PR campaigns will whitewash.

    In his autobiography and outline of his plans for Germany’s political future, “Mein Kampf,” Hitler wrote:

    All propaganda must be popular and its intellectual level must be adjusted to the most limited intelligence among those it is addressed to. Consequently, the greater the mass it is intended to reach, the lower its purely intellectual level will have to be. But if, as in propaganda for sticking out a war, the aim is to influence a whole people, we must avoid excessive intellectual demands on our public, and too much caution cannot be exerted in this direction.”

    On the road out of Aleppo back to Damascus, we got out of the car to take one last photo of the city we were leaving behind us. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    On the road out of Aleppo back to Damascus, we got out of the car to take one last photo of the city we were leaving behind us. (Photo: Vanessa Beeley)

    Be Sociable, Share!


    Print This Story Print This Story
    You Might Also Like  
    This entry was posted in Foreign Affairs, Front Page: Inside Stories, Inside Stories, Investigations, Top Stories and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
    • Pingback: How We Were Misled About Syria: Channel 4 News | Tim Hayward()

    • Pingback: Syria: the Western media's unending propaganda war - Scisco Media()

    • Pingback: Nothing but the Truth in Syria _ on Soapbox | NO LIES RADIO()

    • James Wherry

      It just gets better every day: MintPressNews disproven by Syria and its War Crime accomplices in the Russian military.

      1. Russian accomplices of the War Criminal Assad are using incendiary bombs.
      Russia admits it!

      2. Syrian government blows up MORE hospitals.

      3. Russians are using cluster bombs – a fact unreported in this website, which complains about the House of Sa’ud doing the same thing in Yemen.

      4.. THE GUARDIAN – tapatio’s FAVORITE news site – reports 2,000 civilians murdered by Russian bombers in 6 months. Have some perspective about the Fog of War.

      5. THE GUARIDAN reports that Syrian planes attacked and murdered 30 civilians in a “revenge” attack.

      6. Russian airstrikes – not ISIL – are killing civilians.

      7. Russian jets strike civilians in Aleppo.

    • James Wherry

      More hospitals blown up by the Syrian government and their Russian war crime accomplices.

    • Mike
    • Pingback: Escalation to WWIII breaking in Syria… Weather warfare underway on eastern seaboard of U.S.?… Retributions for all the “work that we’re doing all around the world” coming?… much, much more… | Auribus Arrectis()

    • James Wherry

      In the “Journey to Aleppo,” the traveler does not have far to go to find new atrocities by Assad and his Russian allies.

      “Russia ‘caught out’ using incendiary weapons in Syria by its own channel Russia Today”

    • AMHants

      A brilliant article, just like Part 1. Thank you.

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Fake Tears Followed By NATO Bombs « Socio-Economics History Blog()

    • James Wherry

      USAID supports many NGOs committed to search and rescue. This story is a list of phonetic allegations..

      • scitech

        James you have posted 11500 comments. You are a professional PR man. Your comments are made for money. You are no better than a head chopper. Go Away.

        • James Wherry

          Why? Is there some error or bigotry you’re afraid I’ll catch and expose?

          Sorry, no money. I do this for the love of the truth.

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria... Tears Followed By NATO Bombs - Alternative Report()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs – Equity Fund Company()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs | | Investing Matters()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs | It's Not The Tea Party()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria... Tears Followed By NATO Bombs - - Financial news from every major financial news portal in realtime()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs | ValuBit()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria... Tears Followed By NATO Bombs - BuzzFAQs()

    • Pingback: US Outcry Over Syria… Tears Followed by NATO Bombs – Finian Cunningham | Timber Exec()

    • Pingback: US Outcry over Syria… Tears Followed By NATO Bombs |  SHOAH()

    • Pingback: Samantha Powers’ crocodile tears over Syria prelude to NATO bombs |()

    • James Wherry

      The U.S. FINALLY stands up to the War Criminal Assad and the War Criminal Putin.

      • Varenik

        did you read the article ?

        • James Wherry


          • Varenik

            I must have missed the sarcasm then.
            My bad.

            • James Wherry

              No sarcasm, this time: Puts n is following his playbook from m Grozny, as has been pointed out: “Take no prisoners” and “I don’t care how many people I have to kill.”

              I love it, when the Far Left sets out to support a Purin or a Duterte and it turns out the USA is the one standing on the side of human rights.

              • Varenik

                Putin is also the one that is not deluding his country as to who real terrorists are – the salafists/wahhabists supported by the Saudis and Qataris, with full-hearted approval of the White House…
                He’s quite correct when he says there are NO moderates fighting to overthrow Assad.
                Remind me when US was on the side of human rights again…

                • James Wherry

                  i can’t disagree about the Wa’hab’s or the Salafi’s, but does that void the Kaw of Land Warfare? That kind of thinking is EXACTLY what got America in trouble with torture through the CIA and water boarding.

                  I do criticize and condemn my government for what it did, but I hold hold Putin and Assad to no less a standard, as a result.

                  And despite the opportunistic jihadi parasites who have exploited the Sun’ni’s legitimate fear and hatred of Assad, the Syrian people do not deserve either grotesque group – the Syrian government OR the jihadis. Why should I choose the lesser of two Very Evils?

                  • Varenik

                    Are we still assuming that Syria should not be destroyed like Libya ?
                    Rumor has it Putin watched the video of Gaddafi’s last minutes a few times in a row and probably resolved to do whatever he had to, to prevent it in Libya, along with resulting destruction, chaos, and competing gas pipeline to the EU.
                    And, any country going thru what Russia had in the past 25 yrs, most of it at hands of the indispensable nation, cannot be really blamed for taking extreme measures.
                    The moral idiots in US seem to have no concept of NOT cornering anyone when the only way out is over you.

                    • James Wherry

                      I loudly opposed NATO action in Libya and our support for that action.

                      Classic example of Bleeding Heart Leftists trying to implement “LIBERAL military interventionism.”

                      I think I’m clear: America can’t find a “moderate” or even vaguely “democratic” rebel group, so it should only be attacking ISIL because of its own war on the West and because of the on-going Genocide against Christians, Yezidi and Shi’ites – and then America should not be doing anything else for or with any “rebel” group.

                      That does not mean America should turn a blind eye to Putin and Assad. As Foreign Policy magazine wrote, last week, “It’s all good fun- until they send in the Death Squads.” That criminal action perpetuates violence, and America has already been accused of doing so in the Middle East.

                      • Varenik

                        and the originators of this whole mess was Russia ?

                      • James Wherry

                        The origins of the entire mess really stem with the Ba’athist parties in Iraq and Syria in the 1960s.

                        Apparently, the only way you are able to impose modern, secular democracy on Arab Muslims is through brutal repression and dictatorship. . .

                        Ironically, the Shiites did it to the Sunnis in Syria and the Sunnis did it to the Shiites to in Iraq – but tribalistically Arab Muslims did it I each other, both places.

                      • Varenik

                        So, Zbieg had nothing to do with ‘radicalizing’ anyone ?

                      • James Wherry

                        Brezinski? You would have to explain who you believe was radicalized and in what manner. Saddam Hussein was a thug before he came to power over in Iraq and the Ba’athist party was simply a tool.

                        The Asaads were and are part in f a minority sect. Have you read the book “it’s our turn to eat?” There are no Muslims in the making of the story of Kenya after the fall of Daniel Arap Moi and his ruling party, but it seems that this is the way that tribalistic countries operate: reformers replace demagogues and then become the oppressors.

                        “No radicalization required.”

                      • Varenik

                        so his ‘grand chessboard strategy’ with radicalized in Pakistani madrases, freedom fighters against the Soviets in Afghanistan turning against US and the shia had no relation to US created nightmare in Iraq ?
                        Just because tribalistic countries are easy to subvert to our “grand strategies” it does not make it OK. period.

                      • James Wherry

                        1. Honestly? No: I see no connection between Iraq’s history and what happened in Pakistan. The Ba’athist secularism did inoculate Iraq from such extremism. You’re invited to provide research to the contrary: I’ve just never perceived or seen a connection.

                        2. Brezinski did not radicalize Pakistan: it was “religiously radical” in its inception, when its founders set out to create the “Pakistan” or “Pure Land” nation of Shariah and not a fan muted or secular nation with the Hindus.

                        After that, the extremist, “Wa’habi” eventual result is INEVITABLE. Leaders compete for supporters not by being more generous or noble or economically sound, but by being “Holier Than Thou,” because the premise of the Pure Land was not economic mobility or generosity, but religious rules which in Islam manifest themselves in prohibitions, restrictions and punishments meant to favor Islam.

                        If anything, we exploited what was already there in Pakistan and said, “We have to emphasize how much like THEM, WE are – and how ‘alien’ the atheist Soviets were.” But we never created what had never existed.

                        3. At no time did I say we were exploiting tribal cultures or societies: I was merely pointing out the issue is not uniquely “Muslim.”

                        Tribal societies DO have one major problem that hurts them: Tribes provide members with EVERYTHING, food, clothing, a job, a wife. In exchange, it demands blind loyalty. And THAT is easy for bigots and extremists to exploit.

                        It actually hurts the USA, if our goal is to create peace and stability. You make a Leftist assumption that America is out there destroying societies and shilling for corporations. I do not make that assumption, primarily because the USA is 330 million people with varying motives. Case in point: I supported the invasion of Iraq, but not to help corporations or US arms dealers, or whatever fake motive the Far Left attributes to its political opponents to demonize us.

                      • Varenik

                        330 million do not make policies.
                        The results speak better than rhetoric – countries destroyed, corporations prevail.
                        Ever hear of Shevron tanker named Condoleeza Rice ?
                        Support for Iraq invasion…
                        that says it all

                      • James Wherry

                        No: national actors are n the USA cannot do what they do without popular support – which Bush had.

                        As opposed to “supported ‘giving sanctions more time’ to murder 50,000 Iraqi children each year for weapons of mass destruction that did not exist?”

                        Your dismissal without inquiry or thought is shallow and weak. I supported and still support the decision to invade. It’s never been successfully challenged – at l sat not morally.

                      • Varenik

                        Oh come on, don’t pull Trump on me : “Bush had popular support” – based on outright lies – what kind of support is that ?
                        Why am I starting to feel like you are a bot programmed to have “republican” leanings ?

                      • James Wherry

                        Since I’ve already criticized my government in this thread, why do you think I am “defending republican leanings?”

                        Would those lies be the same lies the anti-war movement was also telling? Clinton and Gore both reported receiving reports that Saddam had WMD hidden in caves. France and Russia admitted having the same INTEL. And the anti-war movements response to the prospect of war was “give sanctions more time.” More time to do what?!? Saddam didn’t have WMD, so the only thing the sanctions were doing was killing 50,000 Iraqi children off.

                        But Governor Bush of Texas was not the source of the bad INTEL from the ’90’s, now was he?

                        I don’t know why you would associate what I am saying with support for Trump: I don’t particularly like the man. It looks like you attribute negatives to people you disagree with so you can stop listening to them.

                        Fine: the insults began about 2 posts ago and I’m really not interested.

                      • Varenik

                        For whatever it’s worth, I said you were “pulling” Trump.
                        It is more of a disrespect for the “evidence” that was fixed around the policies both “parties” (dems and the others) were ramming down everybody’s throats.

                      • James Wherry

                        I can never prove it, but the greatest double agent in the past 25 years was and is Ahmed Chalabai.

                        He spent years passing the information to the neo-cons about the WMD in Iraq and claiming he hated Iran.

                        He is retired today, living in Tehran.

    • Pingback: 28 sep | Syrien()

    • Pingback: US Outcry over Syria... Tears Followed By NATO Bombs - The True News()

    • Pingback: Journey To Aleppo Part II: The Syria Civil Defense & Aleppo Medical Association Are Real Syrians Helping Real Syrians | altahrir, news of Islam, Muslims, Arab Spring and special Palestine()

    • Mourine Place

      These so called Muslims people are really sick. Not only is the regime tutoring their own people. But jihadis are killing and beheading people for no reason especially when you are not a Christiana. And they are proud to say they are being funded by the usa. check here.

      • James Wherry

        Mourine: see my comment to Deb, below. There are unquestionably jihadists of political Islam on both sides of the divide and they do no good for themselves or anyone else. I fear the crisis that would trigger a “reformation” within Islam is not at hand, and that bodes ill for the next 100 years. I also fear that American apologists will continue to apologize for jihadists and blame their actions on the West, instead of blaming their actions on the terrorists, themselves. (exerpt, below).

        Meet the Western Charlatans Justifying Jihad
        by Giulio Meotti
        September 28, 2016 at 5:00 am

        Why has the philosopher, Michel Onfray, become so popular among the French jihadists fighting in Syria and Iraq? Journalist David Thomson, a specialist in jihadi movements, explained that “Onfray is translated into Arabic and shared on all pro-ISIS sites.”

        Onfray recognizes that we are at war. But this war, to him, was started by George W. Bush. He “forgets” that 3,000 Americans were killed on September 11, 2001. If you remind him that “ISIS kills innocent people”, Onfray will reply: “We have also killed innocent people.” It is the perfect moral equivalence between ISIS and the West. Barbarians against barbarians! With his moral relativism, Onfray opens the door to Islamist cutthroats.

        The French intellectual Thomas Piketty, after the massacres in Paris, pointed at “inequality” as the root of ISIS’s success. Another well-known German philosopher, Peter Sloterdijk, claimed that the September 11 attacks were attacks were just “small incidents”.

        Famous representatives of European culture also embraced Adolf Hitler’s dream. Their heirs now justify jihad as the ultimate punishment for Western freedoms and democracy.

        After September 11, 2001, the cream of European intellectuals immediately started to find justifications for jihad. They evidently were fascinated by the Kalashnikov assault rifle, “the weapon of the poor”. For them, what we had seen in New York was a chimera, an illusion. The mass killings were supposedly the suicide of the capitalist democracy, and terrorism was the wrath of the unemployed, the desperate weapon of a lumpenproletariat offended by the arrogance of Western globalization.

        These intellectuals have sown seeds of despair in a large Western echo-chamber. From 9/11 to the recent massacres on European soil, the murdered Westerners are portrayed as just collateral victims in a war between “the system” and the damned of the earth, who are only claiming a place at the table.

        One of these intellectuals is Michel Onfray. It has been a while since we heard the expression: “Useful idiot.” The cynical expression is often attributed to Lenin, and was used to designate Western sympathizers who justified the horrors of Communism. The French magazine L’Express used it for Onfray: “the useful idiot of Islamism”.

        When his “Atheist Manifesto” was published in 2005, Onfray could never have imagined that ten years later, he would become the darling of the jihadist group, Islamic State (ISIS). Yet, on November 21, 2015, a week after the massacres in Paris, Onfray appeared in a propaganda video of the Islamic State. A few days later, Onfray, this idol of the reflexive European middle class, said that a “truce could be signed between ISIS and France”.

        Onfray just gave another interview to the magazine Famille Chrétienne, where he explained that there is no moral difference between “killing innocent lives of women, children and elderly” and “state terrorism” — between ISIS and the Western war on terror.

        Onfray is the most widely read French philosopher in the world and has dethroned Michel Serres, Michel Foucault and Jean-Paul Sartre. This philosopher, drunk with the Enlightenment, has written 80 books, translated into nearly 30 languages. He is not a Marxist, but a libertarian hedonist. According to Onfray, the entire Judeo-Christian heritage prevents free, loving enjoyment. Hence his insistence, ultimately, that the Western civilization is “dead.”

        How did this great hedonist, the theorist of materialism and atheism, become the darling of Islamist cutthroats? Prime Minister Manuel Valls accused him of having “lost his bearings.”

        When Onfray calls for a truce with the Islamic State, it is because he believes that France is responsible for what happened to itself. In his recent book Penser l’islam (“Thinking Islam”), Onfray wrote: “If we look at the historical facts and not at the emotions, the West attacked first.” France is supposedly reaping what it has sown. Of course Islamists kill and massacre, but it is not their fault, as the West, in his view, previously attacked them.

        Onfray also gave the impression of finding more excuses for ISIS by speaking a French “Islamophobia.” Why has Onfray has become so popular among the French jihadists fighting in Syria and Iraq? Journalist David Thomson, a specialist in jihadi movements, explained that “Onfray is translated into Arabic and shared on all pro-ISIS sites.” Talking to Jean-Jacques Bourdin in 2013, Onfray even defended the right of Islamists to apply Islamic sharia law in Mali.

        Onfray recognizes that we are at war. But this war, to him, was started by George W. Bush. He “forgets” that 3,000 Americans were killed on September 11, 2001. If you remind him that “ISIS kills innocent people”, Onfray will reply: “We have also killed innocent people.” It is the perfect moral equivalence between ISIS and the West. Barbarians against barbarians! The 130 French people killed on November 13, 2015 are just puppets of the West. With his moral relativism, Onfray opens the door to Islamist cutthroats.

        Onfray belongs to a long list of charlatans who abound among Europe’s intellectuals. Writing for Le Monde, the most famous living German philosopher, Jürgen Habermas, claimed that “jihadism is a modern form of reaction to the living conditions characterized by uprooting.” Someone should have explained to him that all the terrorists were well integrated into the French and Belgian democracies, and living with welfare subsidies.

        Another celebrity-philosopher, the Slovenian neo-Marxist guru Slavoj Zizek, argued that Islamism may seem reactionary, but “in a curious inversion religion is one of the possible places from which one can deploy critical doubts about today’s society. It has become one of the sites of resistance.” Zizek also claimed that “Islamo-Fascists” and “European anti-immigrant racists” are “the two sides of the same coin.”

        The French intellectual Thomas Piketty, after the massacres in Paris, pointed at “inequality” as the root of ISIS’s success. Another well-known German philosopher, Peter Sloterdijk, claimed that the September 11 attacks were attacks were just “small incidents”.

        José Saramago, a Nobel laureate for literature, claimed that flying two planes into the Twin Towers was “revenge against the humiliation”.

        There were also those, like the French thinker Jean Baudrillard, who said that the attacks on the Twin Towers were actually desired by the United States. In short, Islamic terrorists did it, but we had really wanted it. Or to quote from the famous German composer Karlheinz Stockhausen, the attack on the World Trade Center was “the greatest work of art that is possible in the whole cosmos.”

        The peak of cynicism was reached by Dario Fo, the winner of the 1997 Nobel Prize for literature, who said after 9/11:

        “The great speculators wallow in an economy that every year kills tens of millions of people with poverty — so what is 20,000 dead in New York? Regardless of who carried out the massacre [of 9-11], this violence is the legitimate daughter of the culture of violence, hunger and inhumane exploitation”.

        It has happened before. Philosophers such as Martin Heidegger and Carl Schmitt, writers such as Knut Hamsun and Louis Ferdinand Céline, musicians such as Wilhelm Furtwangler and Ernst von Karajan, are just some of the most famous representatives of European culture who embraced Adolf Hitler’s dream. Their heirs now justify jihad as the ultimate punishment for the Western freedoms and democracy.

        Giulio Meotti, Cultural Editor for Il Foglio, is an Italian journalist and author.

        • tapatio

          Global Warfare: “We’re going to take out 7 countries in 5 years: Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Somalia, Sudan & Iran

          A Clean Break: A New Strategy for Securing the Realm

          “Israel can shape its strategic environment, in cooperation with Turkey and Jordan, by weakening, containing, and even rolling back Syria. This effort can focus on removing Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq — an important Israeli strategic objective in its own right”


          Rebuilding America’s Defenses: Strategy, Forces and Resources for a New Century

          “Further, the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event – like a new Pearl Harbor (9/11 – PERFECTION). Domestic politics and industrial policy will shape the pace and content of transformation as much as the requirements of current missions.” (p 63)


          CLEAN BREAK

          Richard perle


          Paul Wolfowitz
          William Kristol
          Alvin Bernstein
          Eliot Cohen
          David Epstein
          Donald Kagan
          Fred Kagan
          Robert Kagan
          Robert Killebrew
          Steve Rosen
          Gary Schmitt
          Abram Shulsky
          Dov Zakheim

          • James Wherry

            Which has nothing to do with my post. Your complaint is with Mouraine, not me. Your non-sense about “7 countires in 5 years” is of course, debunked by the facts.

            1. It never happened. The suggestion came in response to the relentless attacks against Americans by Iran, Syria and their Sun’ni jihadists allies.

            a. Iraq had already been defeated and a new government established by 2007.

            b. Syria was funding and supporting Zarqawi, the al-Quaeda jihadist who gave birth to ISIL.
            c. Iran. So was Iran. They gave them IEDs and EFPs and helped them develop logistics lines and communication lines into their own countries. Syria and Iran are just getting “blow back.”

            d. Lebanon – no need to overthrow that government, only the Shi’ite Hizbollah that had taken it over and held it hostage and murdered American service members includilng Col. (ret. USMC) William F. Higgins. The fact “TAPATIO” lies and claims to have been Navy is shown by his contempt for that brave hero who is stooges in HizBiSatan murdered.

            e. Somalia – Nope: only al-Shebaab, the terrorist group trying to subjugate Somalia.

            f. Libya – NO ONE but the current administration had any thoughts of taking out Mummar, after he got rid of his chemical weapons.
            g. Sudan – useless human rights abusers of the people of Southern Sudan and the West with their “Janjiwaad” militias (“We rape women becaue we want to make Arab Babies.”).

            2. The recognition of a new “Pearl Harbor” is not a claim that 911 was committed by Americans. Bin Laden proudly took credit for it.

    • TecumsehUnfaced

      The thugs leading my country make me so ashamed. Yes, they are exceptional, i.e. exceptionally evil.

    • James Wherry


    • World Peace Now

      Thank You Vanessa!

    • Pingback: Journey To Aleppo Part I: Exposing The Truth Buried Under NATO Propaganda()